Business Magazine

3 Strikes Law in France Cuts Piracy, But No Boost in Sales

Posted on the 31 March 2012 by Streaming_guru @StreamingServic
NEW YORK, NY - JANUARY 18:  Protesters demonst...

NEW YORK, NY - JANUARY 18: Protesters demonstrate against the proposed Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA) and Protect IP Act (PIPA) outside the offices of U.S. Sen. Charles Schumer (D-NY) and U.S. Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) on January 18, 2012 in New York City. The controversial legislation is aimed at preventing piracy of media but those opposed believe it will support censorship. (Image credit: Getty Images via @daylife)

The entertainment industry has been very vocal for a long time about how piracy cuts into their revenues.  They even convinced lawmakers of the need for legal protection, which resulted in the SOPA and PIPA fiasco.  While most people would agree with the statement that piracy needs to be dealt with, the debate continues, with bi-partisan support among Congress and the heavy-hitters of the internet discussing new possible legislation on

In the meantime, a new report has just been released by the French government about the effectiveness of their “Three Strikes” law.  The report claims that internet piracy has been cut in half in France based upon the consequences of the law.  However, TorrentFreak notes that what the report fails to mention is that the decrease in piracy did not translate into increased revenues for the copyright holders.

Meanwhile, a number of prominent music artists have been quietly pulling their content out of music streaming services because, it appears, piracy is actually good for them.  It seems that people who engage in peer-to-peer file sharing are also the biggest purchasers of their content.

So what’s the answer – let people keep stealing because copyright holders make more money in the long run?  Or deal with the piracy issue and still nobody (monetarily) wins.  There is an alternative, but the entertainment industry is still very distrustful that they will be able to continue to enjoy the huge profits of yesteryear.

Problem is, yesteryear is a blip, an anomaly.  It is highly unlikely that we will continue to enjoy the fat economic times indefinitely.  Economies ebb and flow, expand and contract.  The entertainment industry simply needs to recognize that while they got to enjoy some really profitable times post World War II through the 1990s, that’s not today.

I asked the question above – so what’s the answer?  Video streaming.  It’s convenient, cost-effective, and deals with the piracy issue.  It also has some added benefits.  Television shows have gotten a huge boost in Nielsen ratings after making past seasons available on streaming services.  It is likely to increase the number of seasons that the show is in demand as well, because new fans can “catch up” on shows made available from streaming providers.

An unskippable anti-piracy film included on mo...

An unskippable anti-piracy film included on movie DVDs equates copyright infringement with theft. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

While streaming service subscriptions tend to put less money in the entertainment industry’s pocket, there are still other movie rental & purchase options that will maximize royalties.  Let’s go back to piracy and the musician example.  People who engage in piracy also tend to spend the most amount of money on content!  So, if you give them what they want legally, they will gladly still put money in your pocket.  But the entertainment industry is biting off it’s hand to save it’s foot, so to speak.


Enhanced by Zemanta

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Outside the Law


    As celebrations ring out in France as victory in Europe is declared, Algerians marching for their independence are beaten, imprisoned, and slain on the streets... Read more

    By  Kaiser31083
  • It’s Christmas, but Say No When the Boss Offers You a Tequila Shot!

    It’s Christmas, but you better say no when the Boss offers you a Tequila Shot! ‘Tis the season to be merry or so they say. Yes it’s Christmas and the corporate... Read more

    By  Onqmarketing
  • Friday Follies – No Jobs but Hey, Look at Facebook!

    Friday Follies Jobs Hey, Look Facebook!

    That's all we have lately. Greece's silly $171Bn loan is meant to distract us from Europe's $17Tn debt hole and the US continues to borrow $171Bn PER MONTH to... Read more

    By  Phil's Stock World
  • Air France - No Excuses

    France Excuses

    The news of Air France disbanding is kinda hurting as they were so talented guys,and when i first heard them in 2008 with their No Way Down EP i always wanted... Read more

    By  Rover
  • Belvedere Vodka’s ‘rape’ Ad Prompts Boycott, Apology; but They’re Not the Only...

    Belvedere Vodka’s ‘rape’ Prompts Boycott, Apology; They’re Only Ones with Taste

    Vodka brand Belvedere has apologised for its sexual assault-implying ad, but was the "mistake" just a PR stunt? Plus, four more juvenile ads. Read more

    By  Periscope
  • Strikes and Spares

    Strikes Spares

    "Strikes and Spares" is an Oscar nominated short from 1934 that features top professional bowler Andy Varipapa demonstrating proper bowling technique followed b... Read more

    By  Kaiser31083
  • What Law Looks Like

    What Looks Like

    When Parliament passes a law, the text of the statute may appear online but the original Act is recorded on vellum and stored in the Parliamentary Archives.... Read more

    By  Carolineld